Mumbai Attack, Jewish Angle

By Benjamin Schuman-Stoler

All our Thanksgiving weekends were touched with sadness as news from Mumbai interrupted what should have been cheery days watching football and spending time with family. The details of the perpetrators’ motivation and planning are still being worked out, but we know a number of attackers landed via boat at Mumbai on Wednesday and attacked specific locations around the city, from malls to cafes to train stations. The most publicized was a siege at the Taj Mahal Hotel that lasted until the weekend.

In all, at least 179 were killed and 239 injured.

We at Moment were particularly aghast when we heard that one location the attackers targeted was the Lubavitch Chabad center. The bodies of six Chabad center victims–Chabad emissaries Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg, Yocheved Orpaz, Ben-Zion Kruman, Aryeh Leibish Teitelbaum and Norma Schvartzblat-Rabinowitz–were flown to Israel today for burial.

As for an official response, Israeli Prime Minister Yehud Olmert and the Shin Bet cleared India for all responsibility, despite recent reports indicating that counterterrorism forces in Mumbai were woefully unprepared, and even praised the rescue efforts.

Olmert also spoke of the terrible associations we all have when we hear of terrorists targeting Jews. His comments were poignant and, sadly, too true:

“The images of the Jewish victims and the horrific sight of the Chabad house managers wrapped in prayer shawls are shocking and take us back to images from history that we hoped wouldn’t repeat themselves,” Olmert said. “But it seems that the hatred of Jews and Israelis is what spurs these horrible deeds.

Jewish news agencies and blogs have been all over the attack. Here’s a smattering of what they’re talking about:

  • Mixed Multitudes has a thorough news round-up of the attack.
  • Ha’aretz reviewed Israeli-Indian relations.
  • One secular Jewish blogger was moved by the attack to observe Shabbos.
  • Vigils will be held across the country today in honor of the victims.
  • Victim Rivka Holtzberg’s parents are considering becoming Chabad emmissaries themselves.
  • Benjamin Holtzman, who knew Rivka and her husband Gavriel, wrote this eulogy.
  • Jewlicious posted eulogies of other Chabad center victims (via Yeshiva World).
  • And lastly, England’s Green Party tried to blame Israel for the attack.

Bookmark and Share

2 responses to “Mumbai Attack, Jewish Angle

  1. My thoughts are certainly with all those affected by the terrible events in Mumbai.

  2. i am very sorry. for this tradegy but hashem is going to bring mashiach very soon so no worries. pray everyday. have a good or great chanukah! i was born on chanukah. layla tov.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s